Jurisdiction: United States; historical case commentary. Reviewed 27 October 2026.
Fashion and ice cream can collide when a shop sells branded merchandise. Off-White’s 2020 case against Afters concerned alleged trade mark infringement and unfair competition; the allegations should not be treated as findings that copying was proved.
The branding allegation
Off-White challenged merchandising and store presentation that it alleged suggested an association with its branding. The public docket identified the matter as a trade mark action. Similar visual material can also raise copyright questions, but the rights and defences are different.
Humour does not settle infringement
The earlier article described the Jack Daniel’s dog-toy case as copyright authority. That was incorrect: Jack Daniel’s Properties v VIP Products concerned trade marks. In 2023 the US Supreme Court vacated the decision below and held that the special expressive-work threshold did not apply where the challenged use was itself as a source identifier. Parody could still matter in the ordinary confusion analysis.
The historical outcome and its limits
The Fashion Law reported an August 2021 settlement in the Off-White/Afters matter. A reported settlement is not a merits ruling that either all parody merchandise is lawful or all similar stripes infringe. The practical lesson is to assess source identification and likely confusion, and to examine copyright separately where asserted.

Comments
Post a Comment