Skip to main content
Legally Insightful

Everyday Law Insights

Jon Hamm, Dr Seuss and US Copyright Fair Use

Jurisdiction: United States; historical case commentary. Reviewed 27 October 2026.

Two very different uses of existing work illustrate why US fair use is decided in context. A humorous image edit and a literary mash-up do not receive the same answer simply because both change an original.

Jon Hamm and HuffPost

In Schwartzwald v Oath (2020), the court found fair use in HuffPost’s cropped and altered photograph accompanying commentary about the photograph’s viral attention. The purpose of the commentary, the part used and the effect on the market all informed the conclusion. The actor’s name is Jon Hamm, rather than John.

That decision did not make most internet memes legal. Adding a text box or joke is not an automatic defence, and a fact-specific ruling should not be treated as a licence for every reuse of celebrity photographs.

Dr Seuss and ComicMix

On 18 December 2020, the Ninth Circuit reversed the copyright fair use ruling in favour of ComicMix concerning Oh, the Places You’ll Boldly Go! The court found the particular copying and repackaging did not establish fair use. The original article’s prediction of a future appeal decision has therefore been replaced with the actual appellate result.

The test and the jurisdiction

US law evaluates the factors in 17 USC §107 together. It is not a mechanical vote based on the number of factors won, and “transformative” is not a complete answer by itself. Australia’s fair dealing provisions are a different system. Check the specific use, right and country.

Earth viewed from space with the original Green Eggs and Hamm article title
Street photograph reproduced with an Image Loading overlay in the copyright discussion

Sources and further reading

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

ASIC's $678 Million Super Warning, ANZ's $7.59 Billion Profit and the AI Inflation Twist

ASIC's $678 Million Super Warning, ANZ's $7.59 Billion Profit and the AI Inflation Twist Legally Insightful | Tuesday, 10 November 2026 | Australian law, finance, technology and consumer affairs A superannuation sales funnel can move hundreds of millions of dollars. A bank can announce a multibillion-dollar profit and still worry about customers under pressure. And artificial intelligence might make things more expensive before it makes them cheaper. Those are three of the more revealing findings from Monday, 9 November. Add Google's warning that Australia's proposed online-safety law could affect teenagers' access to Gmail, a new stage of open banking, and two international consumer-law developments, and there is plenty to unpack. The important theme is not simply that regulators are busy. It is that the details matter: who is actually providing financial advice, whether a profitability measure has a fair comparison, when a new legal obligation commences, and...

Ten Tips for In-House Lawyers Navigating Change

Jurisdiction: General career commentary. Reviewed 27 October 2026. These ten tips are general career suggestions, not guarantees about employment or professional obligations. Apply them alongside your duties of independence, confidentiality and competence. Get accustomed to change. The economy can be unpredictable, and the good times never last. It's essential to be vigilant and prepare for tough times, whether self-inflicted or imposed by external forces. Embrace uncertainty as an opportunity and consider what steps you will take if things go sideways. Review your priorities during difficult times. Ask what work needs urgent attention, where the business faces material risk, what your colleagues need from legal, and which tasks can reasonably wait. These are practical prompts, rather than a proven formula for career success. Maintain a sense of humor. Humor is an essential tool that can help you keep a positive outlook during even the most challenging situations. It is important t...

Trade Mark Classes in Australia: How to Choose

Jurisdiction: Australia. Reviewed 27 October 2026. A trade mark application must identify the goods and services for which the mark will be used. The Nice Classification provides 45 classes: 1–34 cover goods and 35–45 cover services. Class numbers help organise applications; selecting a number alone does not secure all goods or services in that class. Choose the actual goods and services Start with what your business supplies and use IP Australia’s classification tools to select accurate terms. A business may need several classes: selling goods and providing delivery, retail or software services can involve different claims. Once filed, you generally cannot add new goods or services to expand the application; a new application may be needed. Examples, not a complete specification Cosmetics are commonly in class 3, downloadable software in class 9, clothing in class 25, advertising services in class 35 and legal services in class 45. These examples are not a substitute for checking the ...