Jurisdiction: United States; historical case commentary. Reviewed 27 October 2026.
Two very different uses of existing work illustrate why US fair use is decided in context. A humorous image edit and a literary mash-up do not receive the same answer simply because both change an original.
Jon Hamm and HuffPost
In Schwartzwald v Oath (2020), the court found fair use in HuffPost’s cropped and altered photograph accompanying commentary about the photograph’s viral attention. The purpose of the commentary, the part used and the effect on the market all informed the conclusion. The actor’s name is Jon Hamm, rather than John.
That decision did not make most internet memes legal. Adding a text box or joke is not an automatic defence, and a fact-specific ruling should not be treated as a licence for every reuse of celebrity photographs.
Dr Seuss and ComicMix
On 18 December 2020, the Ninth Circuit reversed the copyright fair use ruling in favour of ComicMix concerning Oh, the Places You’ll Boldly Go! The court found the particular copying and repackaging did not establish fair use. The original article’s prediction of a future appeal decision has therefore been replaced with the actual appellate result.
The test and the jurisdiction
US law evaluates the factors in 17 USC §107 together. It is not a mechanical vote based on the number of factors won, and “transformative” is not a complete answer by itself. Australia’s fair dealing provisions are a different system. Check the specific use, right and country.


Comments
Post a Comment