Jurisdiction: Australia; historical case commentary. Reviewed 27 October 2026.
Berry v CCL Secure Pty Ltd [2020] HCA 27 concerns lost commissions following misleading conduct in a banknote-related agency arrangement. “Money fabrication” in the original headline refers to banknote manufacture, not an allegation that the claimants counterfeited money.
The agreement and the misleading conduct
Dr Benoy Berry and Global Secure Currency were involved in an agency arrangement concerning Nigeria. The dispute arose after misleading conduct induced termination of the arrangement. The statutory claim concerned former s52 of the Trade Practices Act 1974, with damages under s82—not s2 as the earlier article stated.
The counterfactual question
The damages dispute asked what would have happened without the misleading conduct, including whether the agreement would have been lawfully terminated anyway. An available lawful route is not the same as evidence that it would actually have been used.
The order and burden of proof
On 5 August 2020, the High Court allowed the appeal and ordered judgment for the appellants of $27,078,507 plus statutory interest. The reasons distinguish the claimant’s ultimate legal burden of proving loss from the practical evidentiary burden concerning a lawful alternative. The earlier conclusion saying wrongdoers “must not bear” that burden contradicted the point and has been corrected.
The lesson
Evidence about the hypothetical lawful alternative matters to loss assessment. This decision is not a universal reversal of the legal burden whenever wrongdoing is alleged. Read the reasons and the way the particular loss was pleaded before applying it to another dispute.

Comments
Post a Comment