Skip to main content

IT'S NOT A WORK OF ART, IT'S JUST A BAG



A recent case in the Federal Court of Australia has backfired for a bag producer as the court ruled that there was not a single piece of artistic value or merit in their products.

In State of Escape Accessories Pty Limited v Schwartz [2020] FCA 1606, the claimant, State of Escape, claimed that Schwartz (and her company Chuchka) had infringed on their copyright works by producing a waterproof neoprene bag which was similar to a bag made by State of Escape. Mildly confident in their approach, State of Escape claimed that Schwartz had infringed their copyright on 34 different designs. 


State of Escape's Bags


Schwartz's Bags

According to section 31 of the Copyright Act 1968 (cth), copyright subsists in all artistic works, which is later defined as a work of artistic craftsmanship’. To determine whether State of Escape’s work was a work of artistic craftsmanship, Justice Davies, looked at the artistic elements to the bag and found them lacking. Using the factors outlined in Burge v Swarbrick [2007] HCA 17, Justice Davies found only the only artistic element to the bag was the use of perforated neoprene and that otherwise the Escape Bag design was “constrained by functional limitations”, that were “merely matters of visual and aesthetic appeal but also, critically, resolved functional issues”. In short, the only thing mildly artistic about the bag was the fabric they used, and every other element of the bag was required for the proper function of the bag. Justice Davies also did not take into consideration the intentions of the designer of the bag or other materials used in the construction of the bag. 


Therefore, if it isn’t artistic, then there is no copyright attached to it, and Schwartz is in the clear.


Justice Davies later remarked that if there were a chance that State of Escape could have established that the bag was an artistic work, Schwartz would have been in breach of copyright. Which probably felt about as good as hearing you came second in a two-person race.


What this case is indicative of is a change in the way that fashion companies are dealing with their intellectual property rights. Due to the time restraints (10 years), an ever-increasing amount of companies are attempting to claim intellectual property rights outside those afforded in the Designs Register. But just like trying to put the triangle block through the round hole, it isn’t always a great fit. Attempting to prove fashion articles like bags are “works of artistic craftsmanship” where functional considerations dictate the design will continue to a sore point for those trying to claim intellectual property rights over the bags. Further, any fashion works that use a ‘minimalistic’ design will also have an issue trying to prove artistic choices.


Improper registration of trademarks has also been proven to be an issue since the appearance of COVID-19; many brands attempted to register their trademarks under the newly created class of face masks. Several applications that should have been registered as designs were applied by brands trying to safeguard their trade marks; however, many of these should have been registered designs in the first place, which would not have been necessary.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

How to Register a Trademark: Understanding Trademark Classes

How to Register a Trademark: Understanding Trademark Classes When registering a trademark, it is important to understand the different classes of goods and services that the trademark will apply to. The World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) has designated 45 classes under the Nice International Classification of Goods and Services, with classes 1-34 for goods and classes 35-45 for services. To ensure the success of a trademark application, it is essential to choose the appropriate class of goods or services that accurately represents the scope of the trademark. This means finding the right balance between a class that is too broad and one that is too narrow. It is also important to note that trademark protection only extends to the specific class of goods or services listed in the application. The 45 trademark classes cover a wide range of goods and services. Class 1 includes chemicals used in industry, while class 2 includes paints and varnishes. Class 3 covers cleaning and ...

Some of the Most Influential Cases in US History

 Introduction The legal system is a fundamental aspect of any society, responsible for maintaining order and justice and protecting individual rights. Throughout history, many influential legal cases have shaped the legal system as we know it today. In this article, we will explore the most influential legal cases in history and their impact on the development of the legal system. Marbury v. Madison (1803) Marbury v. Madison is one of the most significant cases in American legal history. It established the principle of judicial review, which grants the Supreme Court the power to declare acts of Congress unconstitutional. The case arose when William Marbury sued Secretary of State James Madison for failing to deliver his commission as a justice of the peace. In 1801, President John Adams appointed a number of justices of the peace and judges for the District of Columbia. Before he left office, Adams signed the commissions, and they were sealed by the Secretary of State, John Marshal...

Surviving and Thriving: Ten Tips for In-House Lawyers in Times of Change and Uncertainty

Get accustomed to change. The economy can be unpredictable, and the good times never last. It's essential to be vigilant and prepare for tough times, whether self-inflicted or imposed by external forces. Embrace uncertainty as an opportunity and consider what steps you will take if things go sideways. Focus on the four keys to success in difficult times. These include staying sane, making yourself indispensable, making the business love you, and adding value. By answering these questions, you can determine what actions you need to take to ensure your success during challenging periods. Maintain a sense of humor. Humor is an essential tool that can help you keep a positive outlook during even the most challenging situations. It is important to strike a balance and know when humor is appropriate or not. When calibrated correctly, humor can boost morale and make you more approachable to colleagues and clients. Keep up with the industry. Staying informed and up-to-date on the latest in...